Selling on a marketplace such as Amazon or eBay and selling on an owned ecommerce store are not alternatives: they are two channels with opposite logic, and most companies that sell online successfully use both together. The marketplace gives immediate access to millions of users already ready to buy, but exposes you to high fees, little customisation and zero control over customer data. An owned ecommerce store requires more time and investment to generate traffic, but gives you total control over your brand, margins and customer relationships.
In this article we compare the two channels without bias towards either one, so you can decide based on your company’s real goals, not an ideological preference.
Marketplace or owned ecommerce: what is the fundamental difference?
A marketplace is a third-party platform (Amazon, eBay, but also Zalando or Etsy for specific sectors) where you sell your products alongside those of other sellers, following the rules and paying the fees set by the platform operator. An owned ecommerce store is an online shop that you own and fully control, built with platforms such as WooCommerce or Shopify, where you decide the design, prices, promotions and the data collected.
The most important difference is not technical but strategic: on a marketplace the customer belongs to the platform, not to you; on an owned ecommerce store the customer belongs to your company, and you can build a relationship with them that lasts over time.
What are the advantages of selling on a marketplace?
The main advantage is immediate visibility: a marketplace like Amazon already has millions of users using it every day to search for products, so you do not have to build traffic from scratch. Other concrete advantages include the already-established trust of the platform’s brand (a user trusts buying on Amazon even from a seller they do not know), simplified management of payments and often of logistics (Fulfillment by Amazon), and much faster activation times than building an ecommerce store from scratch.
For products with existing high search demand, a marketplace can generate sales from the very first days, something almost impossible with a new ecommerce store without significant advertising investment.
What are the disadvantages of selling on a marketplace?
The main cost is financial: marketplace fees typically range from 5% to 15-20% of the sale price depending on the product category, plus any logistics costs if you use the platform’s shipping services. Beyond the cost, there are structural limits: you have no access to customer data (email, purchase behaviour) to build remarketing or loyalty campaigns, you are in direct and visible competition with other sellers on the same product, often on price, and your brand takes a back seat to that of the platform.
There is also a strategic risk: depending significantly on a marketplace for your turnover means being subject to its rules, which can change (fees, policies, account suspensions) without you having any say in the matter.
What are the advantages of an owned ecommerce store?
An owned ecommerce store gives you full control: higher margins because you pay no fees on sales (only the platform management costs), full ownership of customer data for email marketing, remarketing and loyalty programmes, the freedom to build a recognisable brand instead of being “one seller among many”, and no risk of account suspension by third parties. Over time, an owned ecommerce store also becomes a business asset that generates value, something a profile on someone else’s marketplace does not do in the same way.
The flip side is that all traffic has to be generated actively, through SEO, advertising or social media presence: there is no “ready-made” audience as there is on a marketplace.
Marketplace vs owned ecommerce: comparison table
| Aspect | Marketplace | Owned ecommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Initial visibility | High and immediate | Low, must be built over time |
| Fees | Typically 5-20% per sale | No fee on sales |
| Brand control | Limited | Total |
| Customer data | Not accessible or very limited | Owned by you |
| Direct competition | Very high, on the same product | Indirect |
| Initial investment | Low | Medium-high |
| Dependence on third parties | High (rules, suspensions) | Low |
| Value as a business asset | Limited | High over time |
Which products suit each channel best?
Not all products behave the same way on the two channels. Marketplaces work best for products with existing search demand and immediate price comparison: electronics, home goods, spare parts, standardised consumer products, where the user looks for the specific product rather than the brand selling it. An owned ecommerce store performs better for products where brand, storytelling or pre-sale advice make the difference: artisan products, niche products, products with high perceived value, or those that require a technical explanation to be chosen with confidence.
This distinction also helps decide where to invest first when resources are limited: if your product is easily comparable on price, the marketplace absorbs the launch phase better; if perceived value depends on brand storytelling, an owned ecommerce store performs better from the very start.
Is it worth using both channels together?
In most cases, yes. A common and effective strategy is to use the marketplace as an acquisition channel to generate volume and test demand for new products, and the owned ecommerce store as a relationship channel where to build higher margins, loyalty and brand in the long term. Many companies start on a marketplace to validate a product with limited investment, and in parallel develop their own ecommerce store to avoid depending on a single channel and to build a body of data and customers that remains their own property.
At Studio Mate we help companies build the part that marketplaces cannot provide: an owned ecommerce store designed to integrate with management software and warehouse, capable of becoming the main channel over time, even when you already start out selling on Amazon or eBay.
In summary
Marketplaces and owned ecommerce stores do not exclude each other: they serve different goals. The marketplace provides immediate visibility and shortens the time to the first sale, but involves indicative fees of 5-20% and no control over customer data. An owned ecommerce store requires more investment and time to generate traffic, but returns higher margins, brand control and ownership of customer data in the long term. The most solid strategy for many SMEs is to combine the two channels: marketplace to acquire volume, owned ecommerce to build lasting business value.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to start with a marketplace or an owned ecommerce store?
To validate a product quickly with limited investment, the marketplace is often the fastest starting point. To build a brand and higher margins over time, it is worth adding or developing an owned ecommerce store in parallel.
How much do marketplace fees really affect margins?
As an indicative estimate, between 5% and 20% of the sale price depending on the product category, plus any logistics costs if you use the platform’s fulfilment services. They must always be factored into the final price to the customer.
Can I sell both on Amazon and on my own ecommerce store without conflicts?
Yes, it is common practice, but it is best to manage prices and availability consistently across channels, often with management software that synchronises stock and orders, to avoid discrepancies or stock problems between platforms.
Is an owned ecommerce store really more profitable in the long term?
Generally yes, because it pays no fees on sales and allows you to build direct relationships with customers (email, remarketing, loyalty), but it requires a higher initial investment and time to generate qualified traffic.
Do you need technical expertise to manage both channels together?
Above all it needs good coordination of stock, prices and orders across the channels, often supported by management software or dedicated integrations: it is more of an organisational matter than a purely technical one.
