WooCommerce vs Shopify: which ecommerce platform is right for an Italian SME?

Published on 8 minute read Team Tecnico Studio Mate
WooCommerce vs Shopify: which ecommerce platform is right for an Italian SME?

If you are about to open an online store and are comparing WooCommerce and Shopify, the right question is not “which platform is best in absolute terms”, but which one gives you the control you need, at a cost you can afford, within the timescales that suit you. They are two different philosophies: Shopify is a “turnkey” platform hosted by the provider, while WooCommerce is an open source plugin that turns WordPress into an ecommerce store, hosted wherever you choose. In 2026, for an Italian SME selling in Italy that also wants to expand abroad, this difference matters more than the price of the monthly plan.

In this article we compare the two platforms on costs, customisation, scalability and lock-in risk, with a summary table designed to be read on its own as well.

WooCommerce or Shopify: what is the main difference?

The main difference is who controls the infrastructure: Shopify is a subscription service (SaaS) that hosts your store on its servers, with a guided interface and few technical decisions to make. WooCommerce is a free plugin for WordPress that you install on a hosting provider of your choice, with full access to the code, the database and every aspect of the configuration.

This translates into a trade-off that recurs in every point of comparison: Shopify offers immediate simplicity, with maintenance delegated to the provider, while WooCommerce offers almost total freedom but requires technical skills (your own, or someone you delegate to) to manage hosting, updates, security and performance.

How much do WooCommerce and Shopify cost in comparison?

As an indicative estimate, Shopify starts at around EUR 25-30 per month for the basic plan, plus transaction fees if you do not use Shopify Payments, and the cost of any apps and premium themes from the marketplace. WooCommerce is free as a plugin, but the real costs are hosting (typically EUR 15-80 per month for a store with average traffic), an SSL certificate, any paid plugins (shipping, invoicing, multilingual support) and, almost always, the initial development needed to customise the theme and its functionality.

In practice, for a small to medium store the two monthly totals can end up very close: the real difference is not “which costs less” but where the money goes. With Shopify you mainly pay a predictable recurring fee; with WooCommerce you pay more for initial development and a lower recurring fee, leaving room to optimise costs over time.

Customisation and control: who wins?

On this point WooCommerce has a structural advantage: being open source and built on WordPress, you can modify any feature, integrate any external system (inventory management software, CRM, ERP) and customise the checkout without the limits imposed by a closed platform. In recent years Shopify has greatly expanded its customisation possibilities (Online Store 2.0 theme, APIs, Shopify Plus apps for enterprise projects), but it remains a more constrained environment: some deep modifications require higher plans or dedicated API development, at higher costs.

If your project requires special pricing logic, deep integrations with Italian management software, or a catalogue with non-standard rules, WooCommerce tends to impose fewer constraints. If instead you need a “standard” store that works well straight away without deep customisation, Shopify’s rigidity becomes an advantage: fewer decisions, less risk of errors.

Scalability: which platform copes with growth?

Both platforms can scale, but with different logic. Shopify scales “vertically” through its plans (Basic, Shopify, Advanced, Plus): the more you grow, the higher the plan you move up to, and performance stays guaranteed by the provider without any technical work on your side. WooCommerce scales according to the infrastructure you choose: with the right hosting (often WooCommerce-specific) and proper technical optimisation, it can handle very large catalogues and high traffic, but the responsibility for sizing the servers correctly falls on you, or on whoever handles your technical side.

In practice, Shopify offers scalability that is “guaranteed but packaged”, while WooCommerce offers scalability that is “tailor-made but needs looking after”. For an SME expecting gradual growth that wants to remain in control of its technical decisions, WooCommerce with professional hosting is generally a solid choice up to very high volumes.

Lock-in and data portability: what happens if you want to switch?

Lock-in is the risk of remaining “trapped” on a platform because migrating elsewhere is too expensive or complex. On Shopify lock-in is more pronounced: your data and theme live in the provider’s infrastructure, and leaving requires a technical migration of products, historical orders and, often, a rewrite of the theme for another platform. On WooCommerce lock-in is minimal: your data lives in a standard WordPress database that you can export, move to another host or even migrate to another ecommerce solution with far less friction.

For a company thinking on a 5-10 year horizon that wants to be able to change hosting provider or development partner without rebuilding everything from scratch, this aspect deserves as much consideration as the monthly cost.

WooCommerce vs Shopify: the comparison table

Criterion WooCommerce Shopify
Business model Open source plugin on your own hosting Subscription SaaS, hosting included
Indicative monthly cost ~€15-80 hosting + possible plugins from ~€25-30 + possible fees
Start-up cost Higher (development and setup) Lower (guided setup)
Customisation Virtually unlimited Broad but constrained by the platform
Technical maintenance On you or whoever supports you Delegated to the provider
Integrations with Italian management software Very flexible Possible, often via paid apps or APIs
Lock-in risk Low Medium-high
Best suited to Projects with specific needs or integrations Standard stores that want to launch quickly

WooCommerce or Shopify: which should you choose based on your business?

There is no universal answer, but a few criteria help you decide quickly. Choose Shopify if you want to launch straight away, have a simple catalogue, do not need any special integrations with Italian management software and prefer to pay a predictable fee without thinking about the infrastructure. Choose WooCommerce if you already have a WordPress site, plan to integrate the store with management software or an ERP, want to deeply customise the checkout or pricing logic, or want to keep full control of your data over time.

At Studio Mate we follow both paths, but for the Italian SMEs that contact us the choice most often falls on bespoke WooCommerce, precisely because it makes it possible to integrate the store with e-invoicing, management software and logistics without the constraints of a closed platform. It is not the right choice for every project, but in most of the cases we handle it offers the best balance between cost, control and long-term growth.

In summary

WooCommerce and Shopify serve different needs. Shopify is a subscription platform, ready to use, with maintenance delegated to the provider: ideal for launching quickly with a simple catalogue. WooCommerce is an open source plugin on your own hosting, with almost unlimited customisation and no lock-in, but it requires more technical effort or a development partner. In 2026, for an Italian SME with integration needs (management software, e-invoicing, logistics), WooCommerce tends to offer the best balance between control and costs in the medium term, while Shopify remains valid for simple projects that want zero infrastructure worries.

Frequently asked questions

WooCommerce or Shopify: which costs less in the first year?

It depends on the project: Shopify has a lower start-up cost because the setup is guided, while WooCommerce requires a larger initial investment in development. Over the medium term the costs tend to converge, but with WooCommerce you have more room to optimise recurring expenses over time.

Can I switch from Shopify to WooCommerce later?

Yes, but it is a technical migration that requires exporting products, customers and historical orders and rebuilding the theme on the new platform. It is possible, but it involves time and costs that are worth assessing from the start, not only after you have made your choice.

Is WooCommerce also suitable for people without technical skills?

Yes, with technical support or a developer handling hosting, updates and security. Without that support, WooCommerce requires more attention than Shopify, where much of the maintenance is delegated to the platform provider.

Is Shopify better suited to selling abroad?

Shopify has very immediate native tools for multi-currency and multiple markets. WooCommerce can achieve the same functionality with dedicated plugins, with greater configuration flexibility but more initial setup work.

Is it worth relying on an agency for the platform choice?

Yes, especially if the ecommerce store must integrate with management software, e-invoicing or logistics already used in the company: a preliminary technical assessment avoids choosing a platform that later turns out to be limiting within a few months of launch.

T
Team Tecnico Studio Mate

Team tecnico Studio Mate — sviluppo software su misura.

The service we talk about in this article

Ecommerce

Discover the service